Every Central PA pizza argument starts and usually ends at Al's of Hampden on Millennium Way in Enola — the pies built the reputation, the 100+ Pizza Boy taps built the following. The insider's counterpoint is Casero's, tucked inside the West Shore Farmers Market on Market Street in Lemoyne: handcrafted East Coast thin crust with market-day-only hours, the definition of a best-kept secret.
Wild Rabbit in New Cumberland wood-fires its pies on Bridge Street with arcade games on the side. In York, The Fig & Barrel on West Market Street does true Neapolitan alongside 150+ whiskeys. Duncannon's Sorrento keeps old-world family recipes alive on North Market Street, and Marysville locals swear by Zeiderelli's on North State Road.
Six shops, five towns, zero chains. That's the local pizza map — and yes, we've factored proximity to Al's into more than one buyer's neighborhood decision.
Central PA FAQs
- What's the most famous pizza place near Harrisburg?
- Al's of Hampden in Enola — home of Pizza Boy Brewing — is the region's landmark pizza destination, pairing its legendary pies with more than 100 house taps.
Have a question about Central PA? Talk to an agent who sold there this month — call (717) 790-1847 or use the form below.